Stack cheese between two slices of bread then butter the exterior of the sandwich.
If your air fryer requires a preheat, go ahead and preheat it. And if your air fryer tends to move things around a lot while in the basket, place a toothpic through the center of your grilled cheese to keep the whole thing in tact.
Place buttered grilled cheese in air fryer basket and set the temperature between 375-400F degrees for 4 minutes.
When the timer has gone off, flip it and put it back in for 3 more minutes or until the bread is golden brown and the cheese has completely melted.
Carefully remove from air fryer basket, slice in half and serve immediately.
