Set Instant Pot to “Sauté” and hit “Adjust” until it’s on the on the “Normal” setting
Add the vegetable oil and wait until the display reads “Hot”
Add the chicken and cook until meat turns white, stirring, for about 3 minutes
Add the butter and stir in until it melts, coating the chicken
Add the paprika, cumin, cayenne, black pepper, and salt. Mix the spices with the chicken for 1 minute, and then add the canned tomatoes with the juices. Stir well
Add the green bell pepper, onion, and scallions; cook, stirring constantly for 3 more minutes
Stir in the rice and mix well and then immediately add the chicken broth and fajita mix. Mix VERY well and do a final scrape at the bottom off the pot with a mixing spoon
Secure Lid
Hit “Manual” or “Pressure Cook” High Pressure for 20 minutes (NOTE: the timer may begin to countdown on the display BEFORE the pressure pin pops up. If this happens, it’s fine. It will eventually push up – and if it doesn’t, it will come out just fine! Just let it do what it will)
Quick release when done. When you take the lid off, it will look a little liquid-y. That’s normal after pressure cooking – especially with all the ingredients in this dish that produce liquids once cooked! Don’t worry. The next steps will ensure it thickens perfectly!
Press the “Keep Warm/Cancel” button and hit “Sauté” so it’s on “Less”. Stir often for about 5-6 minutes until it thickens up, making sure the spoon scrapes the bottom of the pot so sticking doesn’t happen much. (It’s okay and normal if there is a little sticking at the bottom the pot for this one – it won’t affect the dish.
Once it hits that perfect consistency where the sauce thickens up nice and richly, transport to a large serving bowl (this serves a LOT!)
Serve in one of two ways: EITHER in tortillas lined with guacamole and top with cheese, sour cream and fajita sauce (if desired).OR in a bowl topped how you see fit!
