Heat oven to 350 degrees. In a large bowl, mix together the milk, eggs, salt, pepper, cayenne and nutmeg; set aside.
Butter a 2 ½-quart round casserole dish or 8-inch round cake pan, place on a baking sheet and set aside.
Butter both sides of each slice of bread. Lay the first 2 slices down flat in the dish and cover the slices completely with about one third of the grated cheddar. Layer the next 2 slices of bread on top and repeat with half the remaining cheese. Cut the last 2 slices of bread in half crosswise. Fit 2 pieces of bread on either side of the stacked slices, cut-sides down, and fill any gaps with the remaining cheese.
Pour about half of the milk mixture over the bread and cheese and let sit for about a minute, so that it begins to soak in, then pour the remaining mixture on top. Use the back of a spoon or your hands to press the top of the bread and cheese to ensure everything is completely saturated and the surface is even, just below the rim of the dish.
Place the dish on a rimmed baking sheet and bake until the top is toasty and puffed, about 1 hour.
Let cool for about 10 minutes before enjoying warm. (It may deflate and that’s OK!)
