Ingrediants
This is an overnight cook. Planning to serve at 4-5 pm the next day. Ideally, you will start the brisket at 8 pm the night before serving.
Brisket Prep
Trim excess fat: Leave about ¼ inch of fat on the fat cap. Remove hard fat and silver skin from the underside (the lean side). Round off any thin, scraggly edges to promote even cooking
Apply a generous layer of yellow mustard as a binder
Coat generously with your favorite dry rub
Smoking Part 1
Preheat Traeger to 185°F with Super Smoke ON
Place brisket on the grate, fat side up, with the probe into the flat
Let it smoke overnight
Smoking Part 2
At around 7-8am, once the temperature of the flat reaches 165-170°F, and the bark is dark and set (doesn’t smear when touched), Lay out 2, 4-foot-long sheets of butcher paper overlapping ⅓.
Spritz butcher paper lightly with apple cider vinegar
Pull the brisket off the grate and place on the butcher paper and Increase smoker temp to 250°F
Pour rendered beef tallow over the top of the brisket
Wrap tightly in butcher paper and return to the smoker
The Finish
Continue cooking until the flat reaches 200–205°F and probes like soft butter (Don’t go by temp alone — rely on probe feel)
The point may finish slightly lower (185–195°F) and still be tender
The Rest
Keeping the brisket wrapped in the butcher paper, wrap it a thick towel and place in a cooler, warming box, or turned-off oven.
Rest until internal temp drops into the 145–160°F range
If cooling too fast, move to a warm oven set to 170°F briefly
Slicing & Serving
Unwrap carefully and reserve any juices
Slice the flat against the grain, about ¼” thick
Slice the point thicker or cube it for burnt ends
