Add the rice, water, salt and bay leaf (in that order) to the Instant Pot. Secure the lid, hit “Manual” or “Pressure Cook” High Pressure for 3 minutes. When done, perform a 10 minute natural release followed by a quick release
While the rice is cooking, prepare the egg custard mixture by placing the cracked eggs, ½ cup of milk, nutmeg, cinnamon and vanilla extract in a mixing bowl and whisk together until beaten and combined. Set aside
Once the lid comes off the Instant Pot, discard the bay leaf and add in the other 1.5 cups of milk, the sugar and maple syrup and stir it in with the rice, deglazing (scraping) the bottom of the pot to ensure no rice is stuck to it and mixes in with the milk, sugar and syrup
Now, taking a fine mesh strainer that you can rest on the lid of the pot, add in the egg custard mixture (we use the strainer so it catches the excess gooey parts of the egg that will compromise this amazing rice pudding’s texture). As soon as you pour in the egg mixture, hit the “Keep Warm/Cancel” button and then hit “Sauté” and Adjust so you’re on the “More” or “High” setting.
Stir everything in the pot constantly for about a good 3-5 minutes. As you do this, everything will gradually begin to thicken. Check intermittently for bubbling and then continue to stir – remember, dairy likes to stick to stainless steel pots! Once it begins to REALLY begin to bubble and boil, turn the pot off and remove the inner pot and set on a burn-resistant surface (like a cutting board) immediately. This step should take about 5 minutes from start to finish
Let the pot cool and then transfer to a serving bowl, cover with a lid and pop in the fridge for a good 2-3 hours so that the rice pudding becomes nice and chilled (you can eat it warm too, but I prefer it cold)
When ready to serve, top with as much Cinnamon Toast Crunch cereal as you wish and a pinch of cinnamon and mix it in with the rice pudding. If you want the rice pudding a little thinner after it thickens in the fridge, just add a little more milk, half & half, heavy cream (or, my favorite, eggnog if you want it even more decadent! You can even make it more grown-up by adding in a little Rumchata or Bailey’s just before serving!)
