For the SCOBY: Brew tea in 2 quarts of water, then add sugar and pour mixture into a non-reactive container, preferably a glass jar. Once the tea has cooled, add apple cider vinegar. Cover the jar with cheesecloth, and let it sit in a warm—but not hot—area for 3-4 weeks.
After a few weeks, the fermented tea should have formed a SCOBY on its surface. Put on a pair of rubber gloves and remove the SCOBY, which you can keep in a glass jar in the fridge until you are ready to make vinegar.
For the vinegar: Pour Cheerwine into a non-reactive container and let it go flat. Then pull the SCOBY out of the refrigerator and add 4 tablespoons to the soda, along with the apple cider vinegar. Cover the mixture with cheesecloth and wait another 3-5 weeks. Taste the mixture as it becomes vinegar, taking care not to contaminate it. When it is ready, it will have a pH between 4.25 and 3, with a tart flavor balanced by some cherry. Strain it through a coffee filter and store it in the refrigerator.
